The roll of Pastors who have served Merrill Presbyterian Church since its founding:
| The Rev. JM Ferguson 1905-06 | The Rev. Donald Dodd 1942-44 |
| The Rev. Robert Tweed 1906-08 | The Rev. D.J. Ferguson 1944-46 |
| The Rev. Louis M. Anderson 1908-12 | The Rev. Kenneth Brown 1946-49 |
| The Rev. William L. Carle 1913-14 | Gerald Cobb (Student Minister)1949 |
| The Rev. Louis M. Anderson 1914-17 | The Rev. George Milne 1950-56 |
| The Rev. Aaron Wolfe 1917-21 | The Rev. Lloyd Henderson 1957-63 |
| The Rev. E.H. Edgar 1921-22 | The Rev. R.L. Kortcamp 1964-65 |
| The Rev. Chas. C. Hulet 1922-25 | The Rev. Donald Sawyer 1966-67 |
| The Rev. J.L. Beatty 1925-26 | The Rev. Irvin M. Morris 1970-72 |
| The Rev. E.L. Moore 1926-28 | The Rev. Donald Krug 1977-78 |
| The Rev. Stanley H. Jewell 1929-35 | The Rev. E.L. Neuenfeldt 1978-93 |
| The Rev. Forrest C. Travaille 1935-38 | The Rev. Richard Brown 1995-? |
| The Rev. Lawrence Mitchelmore 1938-42 | The Rev. William Heming 2007-2011 |
| The Rev. Elizabeth (Liz) Arakelian 2014 - present | |
